This famous monumental defense of abortion by Judith Jarvis Thomson predates the Roe v. Wade decision by almost two years. In this article submitted to Philosophy & Public Affairs (Vol. 1, no. 1 [Fall 1971]), Thomson argues by various analogies that the fetus should not be legally defensible as having an inalienable right to life. Her most famous argument from analogy is the “violinist argument” comparing an unwanted pregnancy to a forced medical attachment to a violinist with a kidney disease. The attachment is supposed to sustain the violinist life. The full article without commentary can be found A Defense of Abortion (Without Commentary).Thomson. The full article with commentary by John D. Ferrer can be found here: DefenseOfAbortion.Thomson.
Categories
- Abortion Cases
- Abortion Laws
- Abortion Practices
- Contraception Practices
- Culture of Life
- Ethics of Abortion
- Family Planning
- History of Abortion
- Kinds of Abortion
- Philosophy of Abortion
- Resources
- Scholarly Reviews
- Science
- Sex an Sexuality
- Terms and Definitions
- Uncategorized
- When does Life Begin?
- Women's Issues
- Follow Abortion History Museum on WordPress.com
-
Recent Posts
- 30 or So Arguments Against Abortion
- What does the Bible have to Say About Abortion?
- Citizenship and Fetal Personhood: Weighing the Implications of Heartbeat Bills.
- Is Abortion Safer than Childbirth? Part 3 of 3
- Is Abortion Safe for the Mother? Part 2 of 3.
- Is Abortion Safe? Part 1 of 3.
- Abortion vs. Sacrificial Living
- Fact-checking the Fact-Checkers for Abby Johnson’s “Unplanned”: Reviewer’s Fault-Finding Mission Falls Flat
- Crisis of Conscience: 11 Reasons Why Senate Democrats Didn’t Vote to Protect Newborns